5-minute read
Wearing matching red shirts and carrying protest signs, more than 100 Carillon Lakes residents arrived at a City Commission hearing on Jan. 19, 2021 to oppose a planned 300-unit apartment complex near their southwest Lakeland neighborhood.

City Attorney Palmer Davis remembers that meeting, as “probably the largest crowd” for a city hearing. “We actually had to relocate that meeting to the RP Funding Center,” he said.
After six hours, with Davis guiding the legal proceedings, commissioners approved the plan 4-2. (Following later zoning meetings, the developer did not move forward with the project.)
Such confrontations have become increasingly familiar during Davis’s 25-year tenure with the City of Lakeland, the last seven as its top lawyer. Last month, he announced plans to retire.
In an interview, Davis, 62, observed that his hometown has become “less genteel” as its population has more than doubled since he arrived in middle school.
“There seems to be a little bit more anger out there than when I was growing up,” Davis said.
A steady hand in a crisis

Stacks of document folders crowd Davis’s desk in his City Hall corner office, seemingly impossible to navigate. Former Mayor Bill Mutz knows better: “On top of that desk, Palmer knows where all that stuff is.”
Mutz, who backed Davis for interim city attorney in 2019, described him as a trusted legal adviser who weighs competing interests against the facts and law.
“Palmer hates to have to say no, but he moves into the responsibility to do so,” said Mutz. “He tries to be as accommodating as possible.”
Davis hadn’t expected to lead the legal department. In October 2019, longtime City Attorney Tim McCausland abruptly retired following his arrest in a prostitution sting. The charges were later dropped. Then an assistant city attorney, Davis stepped in; his appointment became permanent three months later.
He inherited litigation he hadn’t previously supervised, with no opportunity for a handoff.
“Initially, I just wanted to try to stabilize the ship,” Davis recalled.
Mutz contrasted McCausland’s aggressive approach with Davis’s measured style. When commissioners get “pushy” about goals, Davis explains legal limits as a “process protector,” the former mayor said.
Similarly, former Commissioner Don Selvage recalled Davis presenting legal pros and cons — “calling balls and strikes” — without advocating a preferred outcome.

When public opinion meets the law
At times, residents demanding action have clashed with a city attorney well-versed in the law.
During the past year, allegations of misconduct at the Lakeland Housing Authority prompted calls to remove board members, including Stacy Campbell-Domineck. Davis has reminded commissioners that state law restricts their authority over the independent agency.
“You don’t have open-ended discretion to remove housing authority board members,” he told LkldNow. Allegations of wrongdoing, he added, are better investigated by authorized agencies.
Development decisions pose a similar challenge. Davis understands why residents expect officials to heed their objections. But Florida law requires legally sufficient evidence, not simply a passionate crowd.
In June 2022, commissioners voted 5-2 against 211 apartments near Lake Miriam Square after objections over traffic and other impacts.
Mutz, who supported the project, said Davis warned traffic alone might be an insufficient legal basis for rejection, given development already permitted on the property.
“Palmer was giving us the right advice all along the way,” Mutz said.
Though Davis anticipated litigation, the developer never sued.
More recently, the Talbot House shelter relocation dispute and public opposition to a proposed data center that prompted a one-year moratorium have tested those boundaries.
Transparency and legal expertise
Beyond zoning disputes, Lakeland’s growing airport raised broader questions about public involvement.
On Dec. 15, 2023, the city announced a 15-year agreement with Avelo Airlines to restore commercial flights, offering fee incentives while investing in airport improvements.
Commissioners unanimously approved it three days later. With Christmas approaching, no one spoke during public comment.
“It seemed to me that this was a done deal before (the) public had any real awareness,” said attorney Trey Harden, who represented residents concerned about noise and air pollution.
Davis defended the process: Staff negotiates, records are public, and commissioners consider proposals at noticed meetings. “I don’t think it’s feasible for the whole process to be in public.”
Despite their disagreement, Harden, who has known Davis for more than 50 years, praised his accessibility and help reviewing airport records. Before the vote, Davis acknowledged Harden’s letter of objection and publicly read excerpts.
Davis has also made specific recommendations. When PFAS, or “forever chemicals,” were detected in Lakeland’s water, he urged the city to remain in nationwide litigation rather than sue manufacturers independently. Davis says that decision saved money, though claims remain pending.
Concurrently, the city attorney defended hiring outside firms for other litigation, saying an in-house team would require substantial staffing and specialized expertise.
He also expressed sympathy for resident groups that have rarely succeeded in stopping proposed developments. The City Commission must have legal basis for denial, noted Davis.
“The best advice would be to get a land use rezoning attorney to help them present their case,” he said.
Deep roots, quieter accomplishments
Davis arrived in Lakeland in 1976 as a sixth grader when his father, Robert Davis, became president of Florida Southern College. Harden remembers visiting the family’s home overlooking Lake Hollingsworth. “We were in the same service club together in high school.”
Upon retiring as city attorney after a 36-year legal career, Davis hopes to travel with his wife and perhaps spend part of the year elsewhere. Unlike former city Finance Director Mike Brossart, who joined Florida Southern in October, Davis has no plans for another position.
“I am looking forward to a different way of life,” he said.
Davis wants his successor to have something he didn’t: an orderly transition. He has offered to stay beyond his required notice as the city’s search committee seeks a replacement.
Mutz believes Davis gave a relatively new commission and city manager room to grow, providing steady guidance rather than rushing consequential decisions.
He described Davis’s approach: “Slow is smooth and smooth is fast. Ultimately, it keeps you from doing things you might otherwise do inappropriately.”
Some of that careful work unfolded far from the spotlight. In Orangewood, a modest northwest Lakeland neighborhood with deteriorating private roads and a defunct homeowners association, Davis helped establish a special assessment district to finance about $146,500 in improvements.
Rather than face a large upfront bill, property owners would repay costs through annual assessments over 10 years. Davis counts helping make necessary repairs affordable — fostering a neighborhood residents take pride in — among his proudest accomplishments.
Though he worries about growing anger in his hometown, Davis believes something more enduring remains.
“That kindness is still there, though,” he said. “It is still there.”


